What’s old is new again—and not just to people who were there the first time. From vintage fashion to analog technology, younger consumers are embracing products and styles that predate them. In fact, research highlighted by the American Psychological Associationfound that about seven in 10 U.S. adults feel nostalgic for eras before their lifetime and are drawn to products and styles from those eras, with that sentiment particularly strong among Gen Z and millennials. And psychologists say younger people are looking to the past for meaning and connection, not just novelty. For established brands, this creates an opportunity to introduce products familiar to older customers to an entirely new audience.

But tapping into nostalgia isn’t a guaranteed marketing win. When J.Crew gave its signature rollneck sweater a Y2K-inspired update this fall, the launch drew not only what the company called its biggest style-launch sales ever but also criticism from longtime fans who saw it as off-brand. The mixed reaction illustrates a tension for heritage brands: What feels fresh and exciting to one generation may feel like an unwelcome departure to another. And a clever throwback campaign that attracts attention today won’t necessarily inspire customer loyalty tomorrow.

For marketing leaders, the challenge is finding ways to build on a brand’s history without becoming trapped by it, reducing it to a gimmick or undermining the relationships that have helped it endure. How can established brands connect with younger consumers while keeping their longtime customers invested in what comes next? Below, members of the Senior Executive CMO Think Tank, a curated group of experts in brand storytelling, customer engagement and marketing strategy, share insights on modernizing heritage brands in ways that resonate across generations.

Learn More